Cottage By The Sea by Robin Jones Gunn


Cottage By The Sea
by Robin Jones Gunn
Hideaway Series Book Three
Publisher: Howard Books July 3, 2012

REVIEW BY JOAN HALL

Cottage By The Sea was one of my BookBub recommendations a few months ago, so I picked up a copy while it was on sale. It was my first time reading any work by Robin Jones Gunn.

Erin Bryce and her best friend Sharlene have just opened their wedding planning business, “The Happiest Day,” initially working out of Erin’s home. As she is preparing to leave for a meeting with their first client, she receives a call from her stepmother saying her father has had a stroke. He had moved from California to the coast of Oregon after the death of Erin’s mother.

Torn between her new business partnership, and the need to see her father, with whom she didn’t have a good relationship, Erin is uncertain of what to do. Encouraged by Sharlene, she books a flight to Oregon to visit her father in the little “Cottage by the Sea.”

Erin’s stepmother, Delores, is standoffish, and her relationship with her father doesn’t improve in the short time she was there.

Eighteen months have passed when Erin receives another call from Delores saying her father’s condition is terminal. She and her husband, Mike, make the journey to Oregon. When Delores walks out, Erin decides to stay for the last few weeks (or months) of her father’s life. This puts a strain on her business and her relationship with Sharlene.

I have mixed feelings about this book. The overall theme is forgiveness, and I thought the emotions Erin felt were very real. Not only does she need to forgive her father, but her stepmother as well. Plus, she wants the relationship with her father and brother (who lives in Hawaii) to be mended before it’s too late. Erin’s character arc is believable.

What Erin heard in the silence was that there were, indeed, specific answers to each earthly pain. Every “why” had a “so that” response written by God himself.
Robin Jones Gunn, Cottage By The Sea

However, I had some issues with the author’s writing. There were numerous repetitions of words within paragraphs. In most cases, these could have been easily avoided, and the word eliminated altogether without losing its meaning. For a traditionally published book, I would have thought a good editor would have caught these things.

The book ends with an upbeat note that makes the reader feel good. Without giving any details, I’ll say that it’s nice to have things resolved, but I also know life and our circumstances don’t always turn out rosy or in the way we want.

I give this book three and a half fish.

image of three and a half drawn fish by British Museum on unsplash

I purchased a copy of Cottage By The Sea through Amazon.

30 thoughts on “Cottage By The Sea by Robin Jones Gunn

Add yours

  1. Thank you for your honest review, Joan. I’ve not read anything by Robin Jones Gunn, but I just noticed that she’s written over a hundred books. How is that even possible without sacrificing quality? Thank you again.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. “When Delores walks out …” What a slimy thing for Delores to do when her husband is on his death bed! Anyway, echo-words within paragraphs bother me, too, but the story sounds compelling, and it’s available on Kindle Unlimited, so I might give it a go. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this book, Joan!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Thanks for sharing your thoughts, Joan, on a Cottage by the Sea. I’ve never read any books by this author. Word repetition within paragraphs is really surprising. The author or editor should’ve caught that, especially if it’s a recurring offense. Not sure this one is my cup of tea.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I can’t imagine an editor not catching them, Kelly. If it had happened only once or twice, I can overlook them. But they occurred throughout the book. Hard not to notice.

      Like

  4. I like the theme of forgiveness, but I’m not sure the way it’s delivered via the plot as described would draw me in. I’m sure this was a hard review to write, Joan, but you handled it very well. I think I’ll give this one a pass.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I couldn’t believe how Delores treated her husband. (There is a twist at the end, but I won’t give anything away for those who see this review and might want to read the story.) I did like the positive ending. Some times we just need a “feel good” story.

      Like

  5. I’ve noticed that not all traditional publishers put a lot of effort into the details, Joan. They proofread and let the books fly. It’s too bad when there are enough glitchy things to become a distraction. Otherwise, the book sounds quite good. I hope the author/publisher takes your review seriously. Thanks for the review!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. With the onset of self-publishing, I’ve seen a decline in the quality of traditionally published books. The publishing companies had to cut expenses somewhere, unfortunately a lot of content editors were victims. Thanks for stopping by, Diana.

      Liked by 1 person

  6. Yes… I sympathise! I have also noticed a sharp decline in the quality of the writing in traditionally published books which is a real shame. I applaud your patience – I would have DNF’d this one miles before the end.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑